Cayenne EV Turbo vs... 911

[Cayven Noir]

Hi all,

This is probably more of an emotional than a logical question, so I hope that’s okay. I think I’m mainly looking for some perspective (and maybe a bit of reassurance?).

I currently have a Cayenne EV Turbo on order. Spec locks in April, production is scheduled for June, and delivery in August. This is my build: https://porsche-code.com/PTXXBZM6

Anyway, we have small children, so we do need a proper family car. We also regularly travel across the Nordics, so luggage space and comfort matter. My driving is roughly 50/50 solo vs. with family.

But when I visited my dealer earlier this week, my SA showed me a 911 GTS in pretty much my dream spec, available now, and slightly cheaper than my Cayenne order. There is no way I can afford both. So I’m torn:

Option 1: Transfer the deposit to the GTS and keep a more “practical” car (Tesla) alongside it for family duties. Downsides are: two cars, needing additional garage space, and the risk that the 911 ends up sitting unused most of the time.

Option 2: Stick with the Cayenne EV and hope it delivers as a true all-rounder. My hesitation is depreciation, and the fact that I haven’t actually driven the car yet. So there’s a small worry it might not live up to expectations.

I’m currently leaning towards the Cayenne, with the thinking that I can always switch into a sports car in a few years when life allows for it more.

I realise this is a very fortunate position to be in, but I’d really appreciate hearing from anyone who’s been in a similar situation. For context, I previously had an M5, which I replaced with a Model Y Performance once the kids came along.

Have a great weekend!

 

[babylou66]

I believe the Cayenne EV will be the best "driver's" vehicle available this year that offers good interior space. Of course the 911 will still be more fun but I would rather have some enjoyment on EVERY drive versus a bit more enjoyment on 20% of my drives. I'm lucky because I'm getting the Cayenne (base ) and have a 718 Boxster GTS so I'll either have SOME fun or A LOT of fun.

 

[benjaminbutton]

Hi all,

This is probably more of an emotional than a logical question, so I hope that’s okay. I think I’m mainly looking for some perspective (and maybe a bit of reassurance?).

I currently have a Cayenne EV Turbo on order. Spec locks in April, production is scheduled for June, and delivery in August. This is my build: https://porsche-code.com/PTXXBZM6

Anyway, we have small children, so we do need a proper family car. We also regularly travel across the Nordics, so luggage space and comfort matter. My driving is roughly 50/50 solo vs. with family.

But when I visited my dealer earlier this week, my SA showed me a 911 GTS in pretty much my dream spec, available now, and slightly cheaper than my Cayenne order. There is no way I can afford both. So I’m torn:

Option 1: Transfer the deposit to the GTS and keep a more “practical” car (Tesla) alongside it for family duties. Downsides are: two cars, needing additional garage space, and the risk that the 911 ends up sitting unused most of the time.

Option 2: Stick with the Cayenne EV and hope it delivers as a true all-rounder. My hesitation is depreciation, and the fact that I haven’t actually driven the car yet. So there’s a small worry it might not live up to expectations.

I’m currently leaning towards the Cayenne, with the thinking that I can always switch into a sports car in a few years when life allows for it more.

I realise this is a very fortunate position to be in, but I’d really appreciate hearing from anyone who’s been in a similar situation. For context, I previously had an M5, which I replaced with a Model Y Performance once the kids came along.

Have a great weekend!

The 911 is a practically unusable car. Beautiful, no doubt, but from the '90s. Uncomfortable, noisy, impractical, and with the power of a bicycle compared to a Cayenne EV Turbo. Just try them both at the racetrack. A 911 is beautiful once a month but practically unusable. It's like an antique. The best thing to do is buy a Cayenne and then a 911 with 4 or 5 trusted friends, only to use it rarely. There's no point in owning a beautiful piece of the past in 2026. You can always rent it... it's cheaper than keeping it in the garage.